Home

Add to Favorites

Redskins vs. the World

What Is Your Tribe?
Lindsay Starke

On February 21, 2007, Chief Illiniwek danced for the last time. The man had been through a lot of turmoil in recent years, and his last dance was met with both sadness and a sort of weary relief. His friends considered him a dignified symbol of years gone by. His opponents, however, had watched his revelry in disgust and anguish. Illiniwek was the mascot of the University of Illinois, a so-called Illini tribesman dressed in Lakota Sioux garb. His final appearance at a basketball game ended a controversy that was not unique to the team, or even to the sport. The retirement of the Chief Illiniwek figure was just the latest example of the clash between sports fans and some indigenous American groups regarding the usage of native people as mascots—a clash that bespeaks tribal feelings both old and new.

Just imagine if you were to go to a sporting event against a team called, for example, the "Fighting Chinamen," whose fans wore conical sun hats, painted their faces a garish yellow, and chanted a fight song set to the musical phrase known as the "Oriental riff." You would likely be quite shocked. Yet even in the present day, many similarly questionable stereotypes are used by both collegiate and professional sports teams attempting to invoke the spirit of indigenous American people. Whether general —the Redskins, the Indians, the Braves, the Chiefs— or specific to a tribe—the Seminoles, the Chippewas, or the Fighting Sioux—these names cause controversy. Yet the fans of these teams cling to their traditional mascots, in spite of the quarrels. Why?

If you talk to fans of "Indian" teams, they'll insist that they aren't racist, and even offer the defense that that their team names and mascots are attempting to honor indigenous people. You might hear them say that opponents are just being "politically correct" (if they remember the 90s) as they point to surveys showing that a sizable percentage of native people aren't offended by these team names. But at the heart of it, it's that these team names, mascots, war paint, headdresses, chants, and all the other accoutrements of fandom are part of a beloved tradition. A tradition that is, perhaps ironically, quite tribal.

The culture surrounding sports is fundamentally a conservative and clannish one (and I say this as a big fan of both Carolina basketball and the Atlanta Braves). In such a culture, tradition and pride reign supreme; to be a fan is to fervently hope that this group you call your own will vanquish its foes, and perhaps even establish a dynasty. When you are decked out in the colors of your team, singing fight songs, shouting the names of your team’s leaders, it's not hard to see a certain breed of tribalism at work. And so an attack on having a mascot like Chief Wahoo is perceived as an attack on Cleveland itself. No wonder people take it so personally.

Being social animals, we evolved to cleave to our group and to defend it against assailants, because it in turn kept us safe, fed, and happy. However natural these impulses to defend a beloved team may be, that doesn't make them right. These deeply ingrained tendencies can cause us to act against our better judgment—almost all of us recognize that racism is unenlightened—and to perhaps ignore what would be obvious otherwise: that it's not OK to perpetuate stereotypes against people who have historically had a pretty rough time of it. Folks, you might not be racist, but you're participating in a racist thing.

This may sound a bit bleak, but I think it's actually quite hopeful. We as a society are changing, albeit slowly. Over the past few years, many college teams have changed their branding, either voluntarily or thanks to pressure from the NCAA. The state of Oregon has banned the use of sports mascots recalling indigenous Americans. And, showing that sometimes these gestures to honor a people can actually work, some tribes have given their blessing to individual teams to use their particular tribal name, as the Seminole nation gave to Florida State University.

We are all tribal, in a way. We want to protect our own. But when these tribal impulses create as much hurt as they do harmony, we must begin to move beyond them.

Note: I attempted to use tribal names whenever possible in this article but use the term "indigenous American" when necessary to refer to people of Native American/American Indian descent seen as a whole.

 

Have you ever unintentionally used a slur—such as "gyp" or "Indian giver"—and been called out on it? How did you respond?

 

photo by Keith Allison

 

 

Carmen Schoenborn
5 years ago

Ugh, I've had to call out people for using "gyp" before. It's amazing how many people don't realize it's a slur. I think that says something about how ingrained tribalism can be in us...we don't even see it until it's pointed out. And then we get defensive!

erty hjntyhb
3 years ago

Because he does it in the cafe for hours, concentrated, absorbed, and that keeps even so, they synchronize their videos and Obama and Merkel Schwäbisch puts in the mouth, it recently a woman has touched 

Simpsons tapped out cheat

 

Clarence McKinney
5 years ago

This egregious habit of Americans doesn't just apply to sports teams. American Motor Corporation naming Jeeps "Cherokees" and Urban Outfitters creating the "Navajo Hipster Panty" are just the latest in a centuries-old tradition of appropriation, racism, and inequality.

com 444
4 years ago

   
The blog is really appreciable and i like to keep on visiting this site once again that it would help me in further thanks for sharing the info.
Imac Service center in Delhi

peter parker
4 years ago

Trust me; this is not the first time it is happened in the history of crowd behavior!!! .It's amazing how many people don't realize it's a slur. No matter how modern and civilized we say we are, there is always some traces in some people! We don't even see it until it's pointed out. And then we get defensive!

solid wood bedroom furniture

Kapil Sharma
3 years ago

I can see both sides of the issue ... it could really offend some people and then that might spread and the university would get smaller, and then it takes years for marketing to all the illiniwek things get as popular as it is at the moment. Ticketgoose Coupon Codes

lili ana
3 years ago

I downloaded mxf converter  free trial version last week, and I converted many MXF videos for playing on QuickTime. This software is good at converting any HD MXF, MTS, TOD, MP4 to MOV videos. With this perfect mxf converter mac software, you can convert MXF to H.264 MOV for QuickTime, convert MXF to AIC MOV for editing in iMovie, convert mxf files to ProRes MOV for FCP X importing.

mila marsia
3 years ago

Thank you very much for posting and sharing this great article. It is so interesting for me alat bantu sex pria boneka full body and beneficial to all people who read obat tatto

sam disuza
3 years ago

I think both are good... winning poker with the help of online poker sites and knowing the best of the slots games internet. you can also check out sports betting there.

Eric Francis
3 years ago

We can not deny the vaccine would be less effective than hoped and does not protect against the strain that is most common in the population. 

emulateur 3ds

 

mas ion
3 years ago

These news are really great and I am so glad finding it in your site. As I see this blog is full of such valuable information like this publication so I will definitely bookmark it. Thanks again for informing us.
Greetings from Sbobet | Ibcbet | Agen Bola
Agen Ibcbet | Agen Bola Terpercaya | agen poker | dewa poker

EMRE ELPARS
3 years ago

Most poular holiday location close to the center of Antalya Lara; long coastline, apart from quality hotels and moving and life away from the mess every year here need our numerous sağlıyor.b to prefer for the tourist tourists y need to ride better antalya yi to travel more comfortable for the more familiar to an endless number of activities and safer journey to do that we  Antalya Lara rent a car  as you are giving service with our valued customers, approximately 17 years of experience in the provision of these services to leave you satisfied our customers are sufficient for us ... we do not recognize borders as a company with all of our equipment latest model fully equipped secure and served in the service of our well-maintained vehicles Results are in constant competition are not alone in this market will increase the competitive quality and price, we want to take advantage of these opportunities in olur.siz cause us to keep flexible ...  
if you want to rent a car in Lara or come we've been here Antalya Lara rent we are with you always as a car ....

shaniya m
3 years ago

Use the link I have provided in this comment to submit your site to 1000+ directories. By doing this you can easily increase the popularity of your site. It's 100% free. Free Directory Submission List