Add to Favorites

Culture: the Engine of Human Adaptation

Social Learning Leads to Our Greatest Achievements and Worst Errors
Rob Boyd

In 1845, Sir John Franklin, a Fellow of the Royal Society and experienced Arctic traveler, set out with a large, well-equipped expedition to find the Northwest Passage. His ship was ice-bound through two winters, and the entire crew of 129 perished, mainly from starvation and scurvy. Yet the rich animal resources of the region where these men died have allowed the Central Inuit to survive and raise their children for at least 700 years. Why couldn’t the British find enough food?

Modern technology allows us to dominate the world like no other species in the history of life. In the Pleistocene, our hunter-gatherer ancestors did the same—long before farming, cities, or the industrial revolution. Modern humans emerged from Africa about 50,000 years ago and soon occupied almost every terrestrial habitat, from extreme desert to tropical rain forest to arctic tundra. Of course there are species adapted to each of these environments: desert rodents conserve water so well that they never need to drink; forest primates swing through the canopy never coming to ground, and arctic musk ox have hair and fat deposits that allow them to survive winter above the arctic circle. What makes humans unique in the natural world is that they live in all of these environments.

Humans can rapidly adapt to much wider range of circumstances than any other creature. Two million years ago, our ancestors were a fairly typical ape species limited to a small part of Africa. Now we are the world’s champion adapters. What explains this change?

You’re probably thinking, that’s easy—humans evolved big brains and got a lot smarter. We can adapt to such a wide range of environments because we use these smarts to solve the problems of each one. We invent tools, clothing, and shelter. Other animals can’t do this because they aren’t as clever as we are. People are indeed smarter than the average bear (or primate), but we are not nearly smart enough individually to solve the number of problems that we need to solve.

Instead I believe that culture is the key. Humans are much better at learning from each other than any other animal. This ability allows human populations to gradually accumulate knowledge over generations that no individual human could invent alone. Such cultural adaptation may be slow when measured in human lifetimes, but it is blindingly fast compared to genetic adaptation. The British explorers starved not because they lacked intelligence but because they did not have the necessary local knowledge and two years was not enough time to acquire it.

The people who left the Horn of Africa 50,000 years ago were tropical foragers. Twenty thousand years later, their descendants were living on the shores of the Arctic Ocean. To get a feeling for how much knowledge was required to make this transition, let’s take a look at a people who lived in a similar environment, Central Inuit of the Canadian Arctic.

These foragers depended utterly on a toolkit crammed with complex, highly refined tools. Winter temperatures average about −25° C, so survival required warm clothes. In the winter, the Central Inuit wore beautifully designed clothing. Making clothing from caribou skins requires a host of complex skills⎯hides must be cured, thread and needles made, and clothing designed, cut, and stitched. Even the best clothing is not enough during winter storms; shelter is mandatory. The Central Inuit made snow houses so well designed that interior temperatures were about 10° C. No wood is available, so they lit and heated houses, cooked food, and melted ice for water using carved soapstone lamps fueled with rendered seal fat.

During the winter, the Central Inuit hunted seals, mainly by ambushing them at their breathing holes using multi-piece toggle harpoons. During the summer, the Inuit used a clever three-pronged spear with a sharp central spike and two hinged, backward-facing points, to harvest Arctic char caught in stone weirs. They also hunted seals and walrus in open water from kayaks. Later in summer and the fall, they shifted to caribou hunting, using sophisticated recurved, composite bows. An Inuit Instruction Manual for Technology would run to thousands of pages. To become a competent Inuit, you’d also need to master the Natural History Handbook, Social Policies and Procedures, Grammar and Dictionary, and Beliefs, Stories, and Songs.

Do you think you could acquire all the knowledge necessary to create these books on your own? This is not a ridiculous question. That is pretty much the way that all other animals have to learn about their environments. They rely mainly on innate information and personal experience to figure out how to find food, make shelter, and in some cases make tools. Many other species have simple, culturally transmitted traditions, but in every case, the behaviors acquired can be and are learned by individuals. Only humans are able to accumulate knowledge and technology that no single individual could invent.

I hope you’ll agree that you wouldn’t have much of a chance. Inventing a kayak or acquiring an Inuit’s knowledge of seal behavior are hard problems, beyond the capacity of any individual. Inventing the whole package is impossible. We don’t have to rely on introspection because this kind of experiment has been repeated many times when European explorers were stranded in unfamiliar habitats. Despite desperate efforts and ample learning time, these hardy men and women suffered or died because they lacked crucial information about how to adapt to local conditions.

How does culture allow populations to acquire adaptations beyond the ken of individuals? You might think the answer is obvious: culture allows knowledge to be shared. Suppose a clever Inuit devises a new stitch that makes seams waterproof; she can share this with knowledge with her friends and relatives without reducing its value to her. Her family’s clothing and shoes are still waterproof no matter how many people she tells about her discovery. As a result, culture allows the costs of innovation to be spread over all individuals who adopt the innovation. But such cost-spreading alone cannot explain cumulative cultural evolution because it provides no reason to innovate. It’s cheaper to just copy somebody else. Culture must also reduce the cost of innovation in some way.

There are at least two ways that this can happen. First, cultural learning can allow individuals to learn selectively. Sometimes experience provides accurate information at low cost. Think of Goodyear accidentally spilling rubber onto a hot stove or Fleming observing his mold-contaminated petri dishes. Such rare cues allow accurate, low-cost inferences about the environment. However, most individuals won’t observe these cues, so making the same inference will be much more difficult for them. Animals that can’t learn from others are stuck with whatever information nature offers. In contrast, cultural learning allows us to be choosy, learning individually when it’s cheap and accurate and relying on cultural learning when environmental information is costly or inaccurate.

Second, the ability to learn culturally can also raise the average fitness of a population by allowing acquired improvements to accumulate from one generation to the next. For example, bows vary in many dimensions that affect performance—such as length, width, cross section, taper, and degree of recurve. It is typically more difficult to make large improvements by trial and error than small ones. Even if small changes are made at random, half of them will increase the payoff, unless the design is already at the optimum. Large changes will improve things only if they are in the direction that includes a distant optimum. Thus, we expect it to be much harder to design a useful bow from scratch than to tinker with the dimensions of a reasonably good bow. Cultural learners start their search closer to the best design than pure individual learners and can invest in further improvements. Then, they can transmit those improvements to the grandkids, and so on down through the generations until sophisticated artifacts are produced.

These mechanisms imply that cultural adaptation comes with an inherent tradeoff. It allows the rapid evolution of superb habitat-specific knowledge and technologies. But these mechanisms only work if people are credulous, mainly doing what people around them are doing. Learning selectively means that you only believe your own senses when they clearly contradict cultural norms. Otherwise you copy others. The accumulation of small improvements means that people are motivated to make small changes to cultural norms; large changes are suspect.

As a result, false—even harmful—ideas can spread. If everyone you know believes that tiny, invisible organisms cause disease, then you believe that. If everyone you know believes that malevolent witches cause disease, you believe that instead. Culture is a powerful mechanism for generating adaptive knowledge on average, but for certain traits in particular circumstances, it can generate wildly wrong beliefs and highly maladaptive outcomes. You don’t have to travel to the Arctic to find yourself committed to approaches that aren’t appropriate to your local environment. Sometimes you don’t even have to leave the house.


Rob Boyd is a Professor in the School of Human Evolution and Social Change at Arizona State University and coauthor of How Humans Evolved.


photo by Jerry Hollens



Karen Kesler
5 years ago

I want to thank you for this article--it's a nice, concise way of saying something that I've been trying to pin down in an ongoing discussion with one of my friends.  He's frustrated with the pace of cultural evolution and feels that we should have a more rational approach to the world, leading to less violence and superstition.  I keep telling him that society is going in the right direction and you can't build Rome in a day.  Your article distills what I already knew about human evolution into a great talking point for our conversation.

Bruce Wayne
3 years ago

The culture has forced us to become like machines. A man who thinks differently is not treated well in this society. You become either part of the society or else the society is going to kick you out. Keep sharing.  read more here !!

Angelina Jullie
3 years ago

Read your post and consider your conversation as totally exceptional and truth based. Best sharing from you!



coco koko
3 years ago

Mettez les voiles de la Marine quand cette collection de montres, vous portez revolver, tout le monde sait que vous êtes sérieux, ces bas prix, souvent ne signifient montres bon marché pour les femmes est à faire chaud, regarder le marché au cours des dernières dû au fait que de plus en plus de femmes ont tendance à être une variété de replique montre regarder porteur peut essayer d'abord décider si le droit ou le passé, en pensant à cette montre pendant un certain temps, je laisse le tableau de vendre le peu qui reste moyen perplexes

lili ana
3 years ago

I downloaded mxf converter  free trial version last week, and With this perfect mxf converter mac software, you can convert MXF to H.264 MOV for QuickTime, convert MXF to AIC MOV for editing in iMovie, convert mxf files to ProRes MOV for FCP X importing.

Patriz Petterson
3 years ago

Great article!!! Good job. It's really interesting, and informative. I'm hoping that you could post more article like this so that many people can learn more about this. - purchase instagram likes

wahyu hidayat
3 years ago

A good website ... Thank you for the information, hopefully more successful Wootekh | Wootekh Indonesia
Greenworld Indonesia | greenworld | MLM terbaru | Bisnis Online<br>

Greenworld Indonesia | greenworld | MLM terbaru

fan guuci
3 years ago

Dislike Michael Kors Outlet monogram? louis vuitton handbags canada You can find Louis Vuitton Outlet dozens of Authentic Jordan shoes other options: Cheap Louis Vuitton Outlet UK Monogrammed canvass Louis Vuitton UK Outlet can be Replica Louis Vuitton UK 55 Speedy Stuart Weitzman Boots typically the most popular Michael Kors Outlet material Stuart Weitzman 5050 because of this Michael Kors Outlet certain Michael Kors Sale bag, Cheap Louis Vuitton Outlet merely Louis Vuitton UK Sale don't allow that to http://www.himag.co.uk/uk.asp mislead Cheap Louis Vuitton Outlet anyone cheap jordans for sale into thinking that Michael Kors Outlet Sale it is the Michael Kors Canada just one. http://www.afpedmonton.ca/partner.aspx Many men and women Replica Michael Kors Outlet may not be http://www.browniesautocarecenter.com/handbags.php attached to logo design stuart weitzman 5050 paper prints , Louis Vuitton uk for Cheap louis vuitton ca price those individuals, MK bags shop there are Damier Replica Michael kors Handbags Outlet at Cheap Michael kors Online Store as well as Epi buckskin options Cheap Michael Kors Handbags Sale always readily available, and also any(a) graced this fashion runways of which year. 

fanSG fanSDG
3 years ago

Michael Kors Handbags UK With 1959, Michael Kors was given birth to throughout cheap michael kors Long Island to a jewish refrain from impression big t-t-shirts along with buckskin jacket. With cheap michael kors the late seventies, shortly fater he began in the style initiate associated with technology (Nyc Michael Kors Uk body. Whenever he / she travelled Michael Kors Handbags UK faraway from at this time there, in Lothar 'utes destination to locate a custom and purchases do the job, where Michael Kors Uk Sale he started in order to hone and high transmission Michael Kors Uk power on the characters, for example singer Diana Ross and he or she Streisand. With this he or she Michael Kors Handbags UK realized what garments is definitely girls would like one of the most cheap michael kors uk In 1981, Bergdorf Goodman found that there is certainly this type of young endowment cheap michael kors then below an order, this is actually the start of "Michael Kors" company. Michael Kors Uk Erika Kors kept a decreased report within the 70 Michael Kors Handbags UK S, although there is several dependable consumers Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors clothing types documentation (19), but cheap michael kors he or she did not hop on the throne of which Donna along with Calvin Klein. During the early cheap michael kors uk xc ohydrates, they instantly favorite, his or her small enterprise in to a prominent Michael Kors Uk small business. However their Italian custom made Michael Kors Handbags Outletcareer inside 1993, he ended up being forced to visit bankrupt. Dirt Michael Kors Handbags UK leisure time), breeze brought his manufacturer Michael Kors UK Online tub areas, as well as glow energy source. Usually functional, luxury cheap michael kors uk "Erika Kors" would be the ideal relaxed garments and star topology electrical power within the michael kors uk online 70 ersus using humour spinal fusion, gotten to the hipster fresh http://www.audmed.org.uk/ bill (his / her brand brazen line, like: "the particular Thenar cheap michael kors uk Squawk" as well as "10021" - Madison square zipcode). He's furthermore captivated the French cheap michael kors A person's eye in the luxury products collection. LVMH volition Erina michael kors uk online gotten, permit them to accomplish people well known yet previous Michael Kors Uk as well as Celine outfits. Erina Michael Kors Handbags UK along with Celine was, on the other hand, following a pair of times, the look to the American design and style, and also gestural Michael Kors Handbags Outlet some sort of 5-year long term contract having him or her. LVMH also bought your Michael michael kors uk online business of any finally on the gives. Inwards 2000, the business with Michael Kors Handbags UK Started out his / her flagship store. Cologne "Eileen" is actually released at the same time Authentic Cheap Michael Kors Outlet UK Online Is also this season, he or she gained the CFDA could clothes. Erina coles still left Celine throughout Oct 2003 michael kors uk online along with begun to consentrate on my brand name. His / her males wearing Michael Kors Handbags UK company available on the market throughout 2002. Besides the Jordan Kors string manufacturer mode display http://www.comt.ca/mk.html Erika Kors inside Erika Kors, positiioned in 04, Erika Michael Kors as well as Kors Michael Kors two lieutenant Michael Kors Handbags Canada brand names. KORS Michael KORS pertaining to mode demonstrate in order Michael Kors Canada involving the collection and also Michael Eileen KORS sequence. MICHAEL compilation of http://www.trirudy.com/mk3.cfm products including women's clutches, shoes, as well as clothes michael kors canada serial. Your KORS merchandise is place as well as denim jeans. Presently michael kors handbags canada Michael Kors provides inside New york, Beverly hillsides, Las Vegas, New mexico, Atl, charlotte now, Hillcrest, rib table Michael Kors Canada open a shop. Eileen very own Michael kors canada manufacturer shows this United states form of leisure. Then he with regard to Celine plus the michael kors handbags canada romance between the sword is how to find out? "They can come up with a Michael Kors Online difference. I'm a typical Us stylus, merely Celine noble gorgeous, internationalization, for example their widespread a silk filled duvet, chiffon, leather-based http://www.cci-icc.gc.ca/mk.aspx most of these costly fancy materials. Joined with your either side from the personality, with a passionate luxury. Celine I do new clothes, for women who live shown view of lifetime, can be quite childish 

Geotextile Jakarta
3 years ago

Culture is a concept based on a term first used in classical antiquity by the Roman orator Cicero: "cultura animi" (cultivation of the soul). This non-agricultural use ...‎Culture diffusion - ‎Culture trait - ‎Culture complex - ‎Culture clash Culture definition Culture refers to the cumulative deposit of knowledge, experience, beliefs, values, attitudes, meanings, hierarchies, religion, notions of time, roles, spatial ...


mas ion
3 years ago

These news are really great and I am so glad finding it in your site. As I see this blog is full of such valuable information like this publication so I will definitely bookmark it. Thanks again for informing us.
Greetings from Sbobet | Ibcbet | Agen Bola
Agen Ibcbet | Agen Bola Terpercaya | agen poker | dewa poker

Haya Sehar
3 years ago

Personally, I have found that to remain probably the most fascinating topics when it draws a parallel to. mehndi designs